The many failed Bush Doctrines

This tag has been moved to P&C
Donator
Paleocon's picture
Location: Cabin John, MD

Interesting article about the evolution of Dubya's failed doctrine(s).

link

This is the internet! In our natural environment, atheists run in packs and have dictionaries! --- JoeBeDurndurn

Because Good is Dumb
Donator
OG_slinger's picture

Quote:

Unlike his father, [Bush] isn't comfortable entertaining inconclusive debate. Bush sees reconsidering decisions or openly changing course as evidence of weak leadership. This stubbornness was born of a success that came from not giving in to his parents' doubts about him and not listening to their advice.

At a temperamental level, the president has almost no ability to accept blame or learn from mistakes. Disagreement, whether from critics or allies, sounds like his mother's nagging and his father's disappointment. Thus criticism has the opposite of its intended effect on him. Disapproval hardens Bush's conviction that he must be right and reinforces his refusal to surrender. Believing he earned his position in life through willpower, he feels he shouldn't have to ask anyone for permission. This obstinacy has been evident in his personnel practices as well as policy choices. The more the media demanded Bush yield up a head—CIA Director George Tenet, Rumsfeld, Karl Rove, Attorney General Alberto Gonzales—the longer that person was likely to be staying around.

Bush's inflexibility is rooted in the old family drama. It reflects not just a personality forged in opposition to his father, but an idea of leadership developed in conscious contrast to him. Where George H. W. Bush weighed options, W. sizes you up and decides. Where 41 saw shades of gray, 43 finds moral clarity. "The son prides himself on being the guy who cuts through it all, who is decisive, not wishy-washy," Brent Scowcroft told me in November 2007. "The subtleties, partly because of his inexperience, don't seem to matter as much. His father, with the background he has, knows that at best you're operating forty-nine/fifty-one—and you'd better be sure that the fifty-one is on your side and not the forty-nine."

Bush makes a point of saying, whenever it comes up, that he doesn't get advice from his father about the conduct of the war. Judging from his father's roundabout efforts to influence him, this seems likely to be true. In his book, "Rumsfeld: His Rise, Fall, and Catastrophic Legacy," Andrew Cockburn reports a visit 43 paid to Kennebunkport during the summer of 2004. His father gave him a memo that Scowcroft had asked him to pass along about Iraq. The president glanced at it before throwing it aside, telling his dad, "I'm sick and tired of getting papers from Brent Scowcroft telling me what to do, and I never want to see another one again." With that, 43 stalked out of the room and slammed the door behind him.

This makes me wonder if every presidental candidate shouldn't have to pass a personality test. I'd hate to think that the last eight years were all because ole' Georgie had some unresolved daddy issues.

Tunneler of Doom
Donator V2.0
Irongut's picture

I just thought Bush Jr adhered to the "Keep It Simple Stupid" Doctrine. Re-evaluating a situation involves thought... and complexity, something to be avoided at all costs.

Xbox Live: Irongut | Playstation ID: Irongut_GWJ

It's Dead To Me
Donator V5.0
buzzvang's picture
Location: Korean Animation Studio!

Reading that actually leads me to the conclusion that Bush 41 got a raw deal.

Psychotic Foreign Teenage Chicks are so hot. - Legion
I find it ironic anytime a healthy vaccinated person bitches about science...on the internet. - MaverickDago

Office Linebacker
Donator
weswilson's picture

Apart from being a continuation of the negative elements of the Reagan presidency, I never had any problems with 41. He handled the first gulf war like a pro, declaring what he was going to do, doing it, then getting the hell out without overstepping the authority he received. It was, perhaps, the most admirable things I had ever seen in the midst of all that mess.

I feel so sorry for 41 now that 43 has ruined his legacy with the exact opposite kind of behavior.

Control Point: A Team Fortress 2 Podcast
WARP: A Warhammer Online Podcast
http://www.deadworkers.com/network

Discretion is not the better part of
Donator V4.0
Malor's picture
Location: Perpetually suspended

41 was the man who declared that the Constitution no longer applied in drug cases, which meant that you didn't have rights anymore if you were black.

The son took that idea and ran with it -- now you don't have rights, period. Well, you have them as long as the government likes you and thinks you're an upstanding citizen -- when you don't need them.

Because Good is Dumb
Donator
OG_slinger's picture

Don't worry. I'm sure Jeb will set things straight when he gets his shot at the Presidency.

It's Dead To Me
Donator V5.0
buzzvang's picture
Location: Korean Animation Studio!

Quote:
41 was the man who declared that the Constitution no longer applied in drug cases, which meant that you didn't have rights anymore if you were black.

While I also disagree with the WoD, that is one hell of a cognitive leap to make.

Psychotic Foreign Teenage Chicks are so hot. - Legion
I find it ironic anytime a healthy vaccinated person bitches about science...on the internet. - MaverickDago

Discretion is not the better part of
Donator V4.0
Malor's picture
Location: Perpetually suspended

The War on Drugs is the War on Blacks.

It's Dead To Me
Donator V5.0
buzzvang's picture
Location: Korean Animation Studio!

Wow.

Psychotic Foreign Teenage Chicks are so hot. - Legion
I find it ironic anytime a healthy vaccinated person bitches about science...on the internet. - MaverickDago

Bilge Cat
Donator V2.0
Farscry's picture
Location: Commanding at the Helm

Malor wrote:
The War on Drugs is the War on Blacks.

Strikes me more as the "War on the Poor". How many upper or even middle class people end up losing their livelihood when they're convicted (if they're even conficted) of drug charges versus the lower class?

Though that's true of most crimes, not just drug crimes.

Executive
Nomad's picture
Location: At the far end of town, where the Grickle-grass grows

Malor wrote:
The War on Drugs is the War on Blacks.

I think that may be the most racist statement I have ever read on these forums.

A man can no more diminish God's glory by refusing to worship Him, than a lunatic can put out the sun by scribbling the word "darkness" on the wall of his cell.
-CS Lewis

Rifle Lovin Whore
Donator
Mayfield's picture
Location: Running around in circles trying to get a nut

Far is right, its a class war not a race war.

Playing WoW as: Vilius (70 NE Druid)

“The only function of economic forecasting is to make astrology look respectable.” John K Galbraith

Durn, Baby! Durn!
JoeBedurndurn's picture
Location: Bedurnville, OH

It's been a while, but I believe the stats play out that poor blacks are amazingly overrepresented in the prison population. If it were a true class war phenomenon, we'd expect them to be imprisoned at roughly the same proportion as their demographics would indicate.

See also the difference in penalties in 'black drugs' like crack vs. 'future President of the United States' drugs like cocaine.


Executive
MaverickDago's picture

Quote:
The War on Drugs is the War on Blacks.

Good to know that no poor hispanics, asians, white people, or native americans ever have a drug problem!

War on drugs = war on poverty, unless you want to argue that only black people do drugs.

This tag has been moved to P&C
Donator
Paleocon's picture
Location: Cabin John, MD

I'm inclined to agree that the War on Drugs is a war on the poor. A kid in the projects can get caught with an 8 ball of heroin and end up doing a 5 year stretch, but a celebrity with 30-pill-per-day Oxy habit won't even get a perp walk.

This is the internet! In our natural environment, atheists run in packs and have dictionaries! --- JoeBeDurndurn

Optimus Primate
Gorilla.800.lbs's picture
Location: New York, NY

I think we're going off the subject here. Even is WoD is War on Blacks, it isn't Bush who invented that doctrine.

Xbox Live tag Gorilla800lbs

Claw Shrimp
Donator V4.0
LobsterMobster's picture
Location: On a picnic, going "La la la!"

So here's a guy whose policy was essentially based on, "Now who's stupid!?" and we re-elected him?

NOTE: This is not a doodle bug.

Spore

Executive
MaverickDago's picture

USA! USA!! USA!!!

Because Good is Dumb
Donator
OG_slinger's picture

I'm gonna back Malor on this one.

While Nixon started the 'war on drugs' it was Regan that made it into what it is now. When Regan put the spotlight back onto drugs during early/mid 80s there was really only one he focused on: crack. And, at that time, there was really only one community that crack affected: inner-city blacks. It was commonly understood that crack was a "black" drug then and while the demographics of crack users has shifted to white and Hispanics, is still considered so. If you doubt it, ask someone who was at least a teenager back them what race a "crack baby" was most likely to be. I'd bet good money they wouldn't say white or Asia or Hispanic or even poor.

Regan codified this racial bias with the drug sentencing laws he passed that made sure anyone arrested with crack faced a much longer jail term (you'd get the same sentence for possessing half a key of cocaine that you would for 5 grams of crack).

Besides, let's not forget that Ronnie coined another term that has a well understood--and entirely negative--racial meaning: welfare queen.

Claw Shrimp
Donator V4.0
LobsterMobster's picture
Location: On a picnic, going "La la la!"

Correlation is not causality. Some drugs (like crack) are concentrated in the poor communities and many poor communities, particularly in the cities, are largely African American. You can say our institutions are designed to some degree to maintain the status quo and make it harder for African Americans to get out of the ghettos, or even that crack has been targeted because it's the drug of choice for poor blacks, but I still don't think it's a "black drug."

So if crack is such a problem in poor communities and poor communities are largely black and you go after crack, then of course you're going to end up arresting a disproportionate number of black people. Would it be more fair, or more "just" if the police were more lenient on crack in order to balance the figures out a little more? Poor black (and hispanic) communities also have more problems with gang violence than affluent white communities. Does that mean going after gangs is racist?

I'm against the War on Drugs in its entirety. Now, I'm willing to accept that the emphasis on crack has caused the program to disproportionately target blacks. I'll even allow that it's possible this was done intentionally in order to target blacks. It just seems to me that the only way to fix that is to actively arrest fewer black drug addicts/dealers. I'd like to think that we don't bend (or break) the law in America in the name of racial sensitivity.

OG_Slinger wrote:
If you doubt it, ask someone who was at least a teenager back them what race a "crack baby" was most likely to be. I'd bet good money they wouldn't say white or Asia or Hispanic or even poor.

That's kind of a misleading question. Of course no one is going to answer "poor" when you're asking for a race.

NOTE: This is not a doodle bug.

Spore

It's Dead To Me
Donator V5.0
buzzvang's picture
Location: Korean Animation Studio!

Well put, Lobster.

Are we just ignoring Meth because white people use it? Crack is wack, but it's not like its the only drug that get people convicted for possession.

Psychotic Foreign Teenage Chicks are so hot. - Legion
I find it ironic anytime a healthy vaccinated person bitches about science...on the internet. - MaverickDago

Claw Shrimp
Donator V4.0
LobsterMobster's picture
Location: On a picnic, going "La la la!"

buzzvang wrote:
Well put, Lobster.

Wait, Buzzvang agrees with me? Maybe I need to rethink my position.

NOTE: This is not a doodle bug.

Spore

It's Dead To Me
Donator V5.0
buzzvang's picture
Location: Korean Animation Studio!

Psychotic Foreign Teenage Chicks are so hot. - Legion
I find it ironic anytime a healthy vaccinated person bitches about science...on the internet. - MaverickDago

Forum Ornament
Donator V5.0
Location: Louisville

Interesting article. When you have six or seven different foreign policy "doctrines" in a seven year span, you know something is wrong...

This tag has been moved to P&C
Donator
Paleocon's picture
Location: Cabin John, MD

LeapingGnome wrote:
Interesting article. When you have six or seven different foreign policy "doctrines" in a seven year span, you know something is wrong...

Now that you put it that way, Dubya sounds like the Dan Snyder of presidents. Why NOT put in 6 different head coaches in 5 years and expect to win the Superbowl?

This is the internet! In our natural environment, atheists run in packs and have dictionaries! --- JoeBeDurndurn

Feed Me!
Bear's picture
Location: Syracuse, NY

Dinky Hocker shoots smack!

Coffee Grinder

Wow, Malor. Just wow. First Nos gets banned from this forum, now this.

I usually just lurk here from time to time, but now is a perfect time for me to post. Heck, I'll probably get banned on my first post, but WTH.

I have really enjoyed the informative threads on the economy, but lately this place strikes me as the bash Bush command center. Every thread about politics is like this. Nos was one of the few here I agreed with more than not. He debated with common sense and facts, not some preconcieved slant or agenda. It was nice seeing a counterpoint to all the lefty rhetoric being flow about.

First he gets booted. Now Malor, who I highly respected for his views on the economy goes out and floats a huge racist line that doesn't even make sense. I just lose a lot of respect for you after that one.

Agent of KAOS
Donator
kaostheory's picture
Location: Helping Jeff Goldblum Pick Up Chicks Since 1993

MattDaddy wrote:
Wow, Malor. Just wow. First Nos gets banned from this forum, now this.

If we're talking about the same Nos here, Nosferatu has not, to my knowledge been banned, and since his tag is still "Got Blood?" not "fired" it would appear that he is not banned (just MIA)

And yes, Malor probably stepped over a line (everyone does from time to time), and yes we do tend to do a lot of Bush bashing around these parts, but we're just agreeing with 80% of the rest of Americans and 95% of the rest of the world.

Fletcher wrote:

Wear the Filthy Skimmer badge with honor. For we have all, at one time or another, been filthy skimmers. And it is our brotherly duty to remind each other, that although the path of the skimmer is quick, it is also treacherous.

It's Dead To Me
Donator V5.0
buzzvang's picture
Location: Korean Animation Studio!

Quote:
If we're talking about the same Nos here, Nosferatu has not, to my knowledge been banned, and since his tag is still "Got Blood?" not "fired" it would appear that he is not banned (just MIA)

Nah, he just can't post in P&C anymore. I think it was in the abortion thread.

Quote:
And yes, Malor probably stepped over a line (everyone does from time to time), and yes we do tend to do a lot of Bush bashing around these parts, but we're just agreeing with 80% of the rest of Americans and 95% of the rest of the world.

The words you're looking for are "Habitual Line Stepper." But it's ok. It's part of his charm.

Psychotic Foreign Teenage Chicks are so hot. - Legion
I find it ironic anytime a healthy vaccinated person bitches about science...on the internet. - MaverickDago

Discretion is not the better part of
Donator V4.0
Malor's picture
Location: Perpetually suspended

What I said wasn't racist. What I said was accurate. The War on Drugs is the War on Blacks.

Look who's in jail.

About one third of the entire black male population will spend time in prison. I submit that if we're jailing a third of an entire population, the population isn't the problem.

Bush Senior destroyed the Constitution by saying that it didn't apply for drug offenses; that even if a search was illegal, if they found drugs, you could be prosecuted for it. At that moment, civil rights for blacks were severely eroded, because they're the ones being searched illegally.

Again: look who's in jail.